How much should you offer on a house in Montgomery, IL?
Set your offer price from recent sold comparables for that exact home type and part of Montgomery, then adjust for days on market, price-cut history, and condition. In October 2026, detached homes in Montgomery closed at 101.3% of their original list price on average, but only 18 sold, and average market time stretched to 44 days. A fresh, well-priced listing usually calls for an offer near list; a home that has sat or been cut gives you more room.
By Kealan O’Neil | November 18, 2026
The question I hear most from Montgomery buyers once they find the right house isn’t about inspections or closing dates. It’s “what number do we write?” Picking an offer price feels like guessing, and nobody wants to overpay or lose the home over a few thousand dollars.
Online, the same worry shows up every week. One buyer on r/RealEstate described a $390,000 house that had sat since August, with two price drops and failed deals, and asked whether 13% under list was fair.
The most upvoted reply said the agent should be bringing market data and calling the listing agent, because the home might be 13% overpriced or might not be, and only the data can tell you which. That’s the right instinct. Here’s how to build an offer price from facts, using local numbers from Chicago’s Western Suburbs.
What the Montgomery numbers say about offer price right now
Start with the market you’re actually buying in, not a national headline. Midwest Real Estate Data (MRED), the multiple listing service for this area, publishes a Local Market Update for Montgomery. The October 2026 report, with data current as of November 14, 2026, shows a market that has cooled a little but still pays close to asking.
Detached homes
- Closed sales: 18 in October 2026, down from 30 in October 2025.
- Median sales price: $336,500, down 1.2% from $340,500.
- Percent of original list price received: 101.3%, up from 99.0%.
- Average market time: 44 days, up from 27.
- Inventory at month end: 45 homes, up from 24.
Over the trailing 12 months, Montgomery detached homes posted 240 sales, a $365,750 median, 100.3% of original list price received, and 31 days of average market time.
Townhomes and other attached homes
Only 3 attached homes closed in Montgomery in October 2026, at 103.2% of original list price. Over 12 months the figure was 98.9%, with a $285,000 median. That gap is a good reminder of what MRED notes on its reports: activity for one month can look extreme because of small sample size.
How Montgomery compares with its two counties
Montgomery sits in both Kane and Kendall counties, and the county numbers point in different directions. In October 2026, Kendall County detached homes received 97.0% of original list price with 54 days of average market time. Kane County detached homes received 99.1% with 36 days.
Across the wider Fox Valley, the REALTOR® Association of the Fox Valley’s October 2026 snapshot shows a $395,000 median, 643 closed sales (down 11%), and 43 average days on market.
What this means for your offer price: homes are still selling close to their original price, but inventory has nearly doubled and buyers are taking longer to decide. That gives you more room on your offer price for homes that have been sitting, and very little on homes that just hit the market at the right price.
5 steps to set your offer price in Montgomery
The right number is one you can defend with data, afford every month, and still be happy with if the appraisal comes in tight.
1. Pull comparables that match the house, not the zip code
Base your offer price on sold homes, not active listings, from roughly the last three to six months. Match property type, size, age, bedrooms, garage, basement, and condition. Montgomery spans two counties and a mix of older neighborhoods and newer subdivisions, so a ranch near the river and a newer two-story in a builder community shouldn’t be compared just because they share a 60538 address.
2. Read days on market and price-cut history
MRED’s “percent of original list price received” compares the sale price with the first list price, so a home that sold after two cuts can still drag that number down. When a listing has sat well past the 44-day Montgomery average, ask your agent for the full history: original price, every change, and whether it went under contract and came back. A home that came back after a failed deal may have a known issue, or a seller who’s more flexible than the list price suggests.
3. Price the condition honestly
Comparable sales already reflect typical wear. Adjust only for real differences, such as a roof near the end of its life, an older furnace, or a kitchen that’s two updates behind the comps. Get rough repair estimates before you write, not after, so your offer price is grounded in costs instead of feelings.
4. Decide between a lower price and seller credits
Sometimes asking for a credit toward closing costs gets you more than a lower offer price. Lenders cap those credits, though.
Fannie Mae’s interested party contribution rules allow up to 3% of the lower of the sale price or appraised value when your loan-to-value ratio is above 90%, 6% between 75.01% and 90%, and 9% at 75% or less for a primary home.
Credits can’t exceed your actual closing costs; Fannie Mae treats any excess as a sales concession, which effectively lowers the price used for your loan. Our guide to seller credits in Illinois walks through the tradeoffs.
One more detail matters here. MRED’s sale price figures don’t account for seller concessions, so a home that “sold at list” may have come with a credit that lowered the seller’s real net. Your agent should know which comps included credits.
5. Test the number against the appraisal and your budget
Your lender measures your loan against the lower of the price or the appraisal. Fannie Mae’s loan-to-value guidance defines property value on a purchase as the lower of the sales price or the current appraised value. If you offer above what the comps support, plan for a possible appraisal gap and know how much cash you’d bring to cover it.
Then check the monthly side. Montgomery’s tax bills vary by county, township, and taxing district, so ask for the actual tax bill on the parcel. Utility costs are worth a question too: the Village Board’s November 9, 2026 agenda included an ordinance authorizing up to $140,000,000 in waterworks revenue bonds, including costs tied to connecting the village to the DuPage Water Commission system.
How the offer price plays out on a Montgomery home
Here’s a hypothetical example, not a real listing. A three-bedroom detached home in Montgomery was listed at $384,900, cut to $369,900, and has been on the market 60 days.
Your agent pulls three close sales from the last four months that adjust to $352,000, $358,000, and $361,000. The furnace is original and an HVAC contractor quotes $6,000 to replace it.
- The adjusted comps average about $357,000.
- Subtracting the $6,000 furnace quote points to an offer price around $351,000.
- At 16 days past the local average market time, with a cut already taken, an opening offer of $350,000 is defensible, and you can explain why.
If the seller counters at $360,000 and you need help with closing costs, you might accept that offer price with a credit instead of pushing lower. With 5% down and an appraisal at $360,000 or higher, Fannie Mae’s 3% cap works out to $10,800, as long as your actual closing costs are at least that much. Run both versions with your lender before you answer, because the payment, cash to close, and appraisal risk all change.
Now flip it. If the same house had listed at $359,900 two days ago and comps landed at $360,000, a $340,000 offer would likely end the conversation. On a fresh, well-priced listing, the stronger move is usually a clean offer near list with solid financing.
Why the right agent matters when you set your offer price
The listing agent works for the seller, and Illinois law is clear about what that means. Under the Real Estate License Act, a licensee representing a client must keep that client’s confidential information private, and the Act’s definition of confidential information includes anything that deals with the client’s negotiating position. So the listing agent can’t tell you the seller’s lowest acceptable price unless the seller allows it.
The same law also helps you. Section 15-15 of the License Act requires a licensee representing a client to timely present all offers to and from the client unless the client waived that duty. Your offer gets to the seller even if it’s below list.
How it’s presented, with comps, a clear explanation, and strong terms, is what decides whether it starts a negotiation or ends one.
Your own agent should bring you sold comps in writing, call the listing agent to learn what matters to the seller (timing, possession, a quick close), and tell you plainly when a lower offer would hurt more than help. If you’re still choosing someone, these questions to ask before hiring an agent in Montgomery will help you compare.
Montgomery buyer questions about offer price
Is it rude to offer below asking price in Montgomery, IL?
Are Montgomery homes selling above asking right now?
Will the listing agent tell me the seller’s lowest price?
Should I ask for a lower price or a closing cost credit?
How do I choose a real estate agent in Montgomery, IL, to negotiate my offer?
Write your Montgomery offer with confidence
The right offer price isn’t a percentage off list. It’s the number the comps support, adjusted for what the house needs and how long it’s been waiting, and it still has to fit your budget if the appraisal comes in tight.
If you’ve found a home in Montgomery or nearby, I’ll pull the sold comps, check the listing history, and help you write an offer you can stand behind. Call or text Kealan at 630-425-8815.
About Kealan O’Neil
Kealan O’Neil is the Designated Managing Broker and founder of O’Neil Property Group, an independent real estate brokerage based in Yorkville, Illinois. He and his team help buyers and sellers in Yorkville, Oswego, Montgomery, and the surrounding Kendall and Kane County communities, and he owns and manages a local rental portfolio, so he approaches every decision as both a broker and an investor. Call or text Kealan at 630-425-8815.
This post is general information about real estate in the Fox Valley, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Real estate laws, tax rules, and municipal ordinances change, and how they apply depends on your specific situation. Talk with a licensed attorney, CPA, or lender before making decisions about a purchase, sale, or tax matter. O’Neil Property Group is a licensed Illinois real estate brokerage.